How to contest a will in Quebec

Grounds for contesting

  • Formal defect: holograph will not entirely handwritten, witnessed will not meeting the requirements (arts. 726-730 C.C.Q.);
  • Incapacity of the testator at the time of making the will (lack of sound mind, art. 703);
  • Captation or undue influence: the will was obtained through fraudulent manoeuvres or pressure;
  • Revocation by a later will or by divorce (art. 764 for the former spouse);
  • legacies to persons prohibited from receiving (e.g. caregiver, witness, art. 761).

Procedure

Holograph and witnessed wills must be probated by the court or a notary; an interested person can contest the probate or file an application in annulment of the will before the Superior Court. A notarial will is authentic and can only be contested by an improbation procedure or for incapacity. The action is generally prescribed by 3 years from knowledge of the facts.

Evidence

Medical records, testimony from the notary, witnesses and relatives, and the circumstances of the will (isolation, dependence, sudden change of beneficiaries) are decisive. The burden is on the person contesting.

Alternatives

A person who was owed support by the deceased (spouse, child) may, even without contesting the will, claim a contribution from the succession within 6 months of the death (arts. 684 ff. C.C.Q.). Mediation between heirs is often effective.

Related Posts