Odour nuisances in Quebec: legal recourses

Sources and legal framework

Odours from farms, industrial plants, composting sites, restaurants or a neighbour may constitute a nuisance. Several regimes may apply:

  • Civil law: neighbours must not cause annoyances exceeding the limits of tolerance (art. 976 C.C.Q.), without proof of fault being required;
  • Environmental law: the Environment Quality Act prohibits emitting contaminants likely to affect well-being or comfort (s. 20) and requires authorizations for many activities;
  • Municipal by-laws on nuisances and zoning; agricultural activities benefit from some protection under the Act respecting the preservation of agricultural land and agricultural activities (separation distances).

Recourses

  1. Document the odours: logbook, dates, duration, intensity, witnesses.
  2. Complaint to the municipality and to the Ministère de l’Environnement (urgence-environnement).
  3. Formal notice to the source.
  4. Action for an injunction and damages; when many residents are affected, a class action is possible (e.g. cement plant, landfill cases).

A lawyer can coordinate expert evidence (odour measurements) and the different recourses.

Related Posts